There's a wonderful book by Alain de Botton called, The Consolations of Philosophy. One of Botton's distinct gifts as a writer and thinker is his ability to take complicated and often daunting subject matters and make them lucid, and dare I say fun.
In the beginning of his book he talks about the importance of thinking for one self and how doing so is often not popular.
He tells the story of Socrates, the classical Greek philosopher sentenced to death for corrupting the youth and failing to worship the city's gods.
Not surprisingly, the image that probably popped into your head was the painting done by Jacques-Louis David in Paris in 1786. The image shows Socrates surrounded by distraught friends as he defiantly prepares for his death.
"I am not going to alter my conduct, not even if I have to die a hundred deaths," Socrates supposedly told a jury.
To many the boldness of Socrates may be viewed as recklessness. He did after all have several opportunities to avoid death, namely by repudiating his beliefs and refraining from public discourse.
He refused.
To point he was trying to make is what's popular is not always right.
His jury of "peers" consisted of 500 men. 220 decided Socrates was not guilty, while the other 280 felt differently.
But what was their reasoning based on?
By the way,the qualifications to serve on the jury in Athens around the year 399 BC were the following:
-- being male
-- having citizenship
Talk about a low bar.
In other words, having the capacity to at least try and interpret why something was true by considering why it's alternatives were false was not a pre-requisite.
Which makes me wonder if it is for many of us today.
Most people give greater thought to how to make their favorite dish for a dinner party than whether the beliefs they've adopted are actually their own.
The truth is, the act of pursuing mental and moral well-being hinges on our ability to discount the unfounded link between approval of others and the TRUTH.
The two are NOT binary.
Botton says, "The validity of an idea or action is determined not by whether it is widely believed or widely reviled but by whether it obeys the rules of logic."
Courage, as he puts it, is intelligent endurance. It is the capacity to understand that truth is not about the number of people who may oppose it but rather their reasoning for doing so.
Do we have the courage to look BEHIND the critique of others? Ourselves?
The ability to not buckle under times of unpopularity takes courage, which is cultivated with practice. It's not about blindly clinging to our beliefs for the sake of defiance, but challenging others, however many, to prove its premise through logic, not emotion.
In the end, it seems Socrates was vindicated. Shortly after his death the mood around Athens changed like a season.
The three men who brought the charges against Socrates were supposedly banished, one was even condemned to death. Meanwhile, a bronze statue of Socrates was crafted by the sculpture Lysippos.
Athens, as Socrates predicted, came around and saw things the way he did.
The lesson is to not be intimidated by bad thinking NO MATTER who, or from how many it comes from.
Showing posts with label philosopher. Show all posts
Showing posts with label philosopher. Show all posts
Thursday, December 28, 2017
Friday, September 29, 2017
Friendship
I listen to a podcast called, On Being with Krista Tippett. On a recent episode she replayed an interview with very interesting man named, John O'Donohue, an Irish poet, philosopher, and former priest.
Tippett's interview with O'Donohue was one of the last he gave before his unexpected death in 2008.
Tippett's interview with O'Donohue was one of the last he gave before his unexpected death in 2008.
I found part of the interview particularly interesting as I'd been reflecting a great deal on the relationships in my own life. Specifically, how they evolve and grow over time. I perked up when I heard Tippet ask if our generation is less capable of love, commitment, and meaningful relationships to which O'Donohue responded by saying the following:
I don’t think we’re less capable at all. I think we’re more unpracticed
at it and there for more desperate for it. I think it’s a matter of attention really. That if you
really knew how vital to your whole spirit and being and character and mind and
health friendship actually is you will take time for it.
The trouble is for so many of us that we have to be in
trouble before we remember what’s essential... you hold desperately to things that make you
miserable. And that sometimes you only realize what you have when you're almost
about to lose it.
I think it’d be great to step back a little at one’s life and
see around -- who are those who hold me dear? Who truly see me? And those that
I need? And to be able to go to them in a different way.
Labels:
being,
character,
friendship,
health,
Irish,
John O'Donohue,
Krista Tippett,
mind,
On Being,
philosopher,
poet,
priest,
spirit,
time
Tuesday, March 14, 2017
Wing Chun Ain't Enough - A Story About Bruce Lee
There's a famous story about how Bruce Lee was challenged to a fight by affiliates of the Gee Yau Seah Academy in 1964. Members of this particular organization took offense to Lee's bravado and weren't particularly keen on his method of teaching.
Lee accepted the challenge and ended up fighting a man named, Wong Jack Man, a Wing Chun stylist. The fight went on for longer than Lee anticipated but he ended up the victor.
What Lee discovered afterwards was quite interesting. Because he was only versed in Wing Chun, his options during the exchange were relatively limited. His capacity to counter certain moves and adopt a flexible methodology were constrained because he only knew one type of martial art well. In other words, there were significant weaknesses in his craft.
He then went on a quest to learn and master other types of self-defense. It was this philosophy that permeated his approach to life in general.
Not only was Lee an amazing martial artist but he designed jewelry, exercise equipment, was a philosopher, screenwriter, actor, and filmmaker. He never allowed himself to be limited in any arena of his life, nor was he embarrassed by the fact he didn't know how to do something. He just found out how to do it.
In his own words, "To hell with circumstances; I create opportunities."
Lee accepted the challenge and ended up fighting a man named, Wong Jack Man, a Wing Chun stylist. The fight went on for longer than Lee anticipated but he ended up the victor.
What Lee discovered afterwards was quite interesting. Because he was only versed in Wing Chun, his options during the exchange were relatively limited. His capacity to counter certain moves and adopt a flexible methodology were constrained because he only knew one type of martial art well. In other words, there were significant weaknesses in his craft.
He then went on a quest to learn and master other types of self-defense. It was this philosophy that permeated his approach to life in general.
Not only was Lee an amazing martial artist but he designed jewelry, exercise equipment, was a philosopher, screenwriter, actor, and filmmaker. He never allowed himself to be limited in any arena of his life, nor was he embarrassed by the fact he didn't know how to do something. He just found out how to do it.
In his own words, "To hell with circumstances; I create opportunities."
Thursday, December 1, 2016
Having Ideas is Not Unique
It's estimated that we have between 35 - 50 thoughts a minute. Needless to say, thoughts are not unique, not even good ones.
We probably all have a relative, friend, or colleague who's been pitching his or her idea for the next great screenplay, book, or film to us for years. You may have even silently concluded, I'd see that movie, or buy that book.
What IS unique is the ability to execute on those ideas. It's the quality that separates those who succeed and make meaningful creative contributions from those who simply go on talking about it wondering what might have been.
As, German philosopher Friedrich Engels once noted, "An ounce of action is worth a ton of theory."
We probably all have a relative, friend, or colleague who's been pitching his or her idea for the next great screenplay, book, or film to us for years. You may have even silently concluded, I'd see that movie, or buy that book.
What IS unique is the ability to execute on those ideas. It's the quality that separates those who succeed and make meaningful creative contributions from those who simply go on talking about it wondering what might have been.
As, German philosopher Friedrich Engels once noted, "An ounce of action is worth a ton of theory."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)